Canteen Magazine’s Naked Judging: Mary Ellen Bartley
A New York City native, Mary Ellen now resides in Wainscott, on the east end of Long Island. She earned her BFA at Purchase College, where she began her fine art studies in painting and drawing. Bartley was chosen as a Photolucida Critical Mass top 50 photographer in 2012 and 2011. A combination of her book projects was exhibited in a solo show at The Drawing Room Gallery in East Hampton last summer and she was chosen by the painter Ross Bleckner to exhibit her work alongside his at the Parrish Art Museum in Southampton, New York. Other recent shows include Out of Print, Altered Books at The Bakersfield Art Museum, Anthology at The Southeast Museum of Photography, Exposure 2012 at the Photographic Resource Center juried by Alison Nordstrom and Equivalents at Photo Center NW juried by W. M. Hunt.
The first round of jurors created this response:
These are great. I wonder if these are the artist’s own images of water, or are they appropriating the images. Not that that matters. I really like that one with the rip–it works because it simulates a wave — at once a literal and figurative representation. I like the tactileness of these. A consistent mood. It’s not precious. Each image adds something to the series–a lesser photographer would have simply used one of the ideas from this series and submitted 8 images in that single style. Contemporary view on what photography has become. Elliptical vignette (#6) is the only one that doesn’t work for me–seems a bit hokey.
Note by me: The interesting thing is that what excited the first round jurors was a flaw for the second round of judges: the rip in the photograph.
Photographer’s Response to the Judging….
I decided to enter the contest to support the pioneering efforts of Canteen to create a new kind of photo contest and to take a chance on getting feedback on an in-progress series from some really smart and plugged in jurors. I went to the live judging in Brooklyn where there were less than twenty spectators sprinkled in a fairly large auditorium. It was very engaging for the most part, a messy experiment with a lot of generosity, spirit and a bit of suspense and drama. I was sitting right there when Susan Bright strongly suggested I should get voted off the island, ouch! Then Amy Stein single handedly pull me back from the abyss, phew!
I can’t say exactly what I learned from watching the process except that judging art, especially picking winners, is difficult, flawed and maybe a little silly. Watching this transparent process made me realize there are many ways fine work falls through the cracks. Yet how great is it that we photographers have opportunities like this to get our work in front of people who are influential, passionate about photography and so game to foster more conversations about it ? I was so happy to meet Amy, Susan, Arnold and Anthony briefly after the event, they were lovely. Later I had the pleasure of chatting with some of the fine folks at Canteen, Stephen Pierson the publisher and JJ Sulin the art director, among them. They are really dynamic and I plan to follow their work closely. Hats off to the organizers and participants!
The work is improvisational. I record the fleeting light touching the various skins, matte, luster or gloss of the prints as I place them throughout the rooms of my house. I further explore the surface and materiality of the prints by folding, scratching or tearing them before shooting them again. Besides the layering of surfaces there is a more subtle aspect: the layering of time, place and mood, which I’m exploring. The action on the surface of the prints underscores the flatness of the photographs and the “drawing with light” that is the very stuff of photography.
Posts on Lenscratch may not be reproduced without the permission of the Lenscratch staff and the photographer.
Sophie Calle: Detachment, Death, and DialogueJanuary 16th, 2020
2019 in the Rear View MirrorDecember 31st, 2019
Paris Photo 2019December 23rd, 2019
Now What? Thoughts on the future of photographyOctober 10th, 2019
The Myths and Realities of Artistic CollaborationsFebruary 27th, 2019